The Challenges of Proving Copyright Infringement in Cross-Border Intellectual Property Disputes

In today’s globalized world, intellectual property (IP) rights have become a critical issue in the entertainment industry, especially when it comes to cross-border disputes where laws tend to differ. Among these issues, none seem to be gaining more traction than copyright infringement. 

In recent news, a Ghanaian music artist has sued an A-list American artist for copyright infringement. While technology has made it easier for creators to share work, artists and businesses are increasingly facing cross-border IP disputes. One of the biggest challenges is proving copyright infringement in these disputes.

The complexities of proving ownership and legitimacy across different jurisdictions can often make resolving such disputes a daunting task for even the most seasoned of legal practitioners. The sheer number of potential pitfalls involved, combined with the inconsistent application of international IP laws, makes it all too easy for those accused of copyright infringement to slip through the cracks. Nevertheless, as the world continues to become more interconnected, it has never been more important to find a way to safeguard the creative works of individuals and companies alike.

Infringement. It’s a niggling, frustrating issue that plagues the artistic world. 

How do you navigate the intricate complexities of cross-border IP disputes? How do you prove, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that your precious creation has been pilfered unfairly? The answer is simple: you don’t. You roll up your sleeves, strap on your boots, and dive into the murky depths of the legal dilemma that is copyright infringement.


Understanding cross-border intellectual property disputes.

The legal frameworks for copyright law differ from country to country. In Ghana, copyright law is governed by the Copyright Act of 2005. This act grants the creator of a work exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute, and perform the work. These rights last for the life of the author plus 70 years. Similarly, in the United States, copyright law is governed by the Copyright Act of 1976, which grants similar rights to the creator of a work.

In addition to national laws, international law also plays a role in copyright law. The Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works is an international agreement that provides minimum standards of protection for copyright holders. The agreement allows for reciprocity between member countries, which means that copyright holders in one country are protected in other member countries.

Navigating cross-border IP disputes can be akin to solving a complex puzzle. From the intricate web of tangled international IP laws to the thorny issues of conflicting jurisdictions and jurisdictional competence, proving copyright infringement across borders is a minefield. The burden of proof falls on the person alleging copyright infringement to ensure that they have adequate evidence to support their claim. Throw in the vexing problem of cultural differences where what might be considered acceptable in one country may not be in another, coupled with the challenges of enforcing judgements across borders, and the complexities only mount. 


Overcoming challenges in proving copyright infringement.

One approach to these challenges is to advert better international cooperation and harmonization of copyright laws. Through organizations like the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), we can promote greater harmonization between legal systems to develop a global mechanism for resolving these disputes. Nevertheless, it’s important to encourage bilateral and multilateral agreements amongst individual countries to facilitate the mutual acknowledgment of national copyright laws.

Particularly in this part of the world, it is also worth exploring technology in protecting copyright. The introduction of digital watermarks and blockchain technology can now be utilized by creators to prove ownership of their works and track unauthorized use.

In the world of cross border IP disputes, proving copyright infringement is not an easy task, particularly when dealing with the intricate complexities of international law. With various legal systems and cultural differences at play, navigating the often obscure circumstances of copyright protection can have experienced lawyers feeling disoriented. 

But it is not impossible, and the rewards are great: securing a victory in the court of intellectual property not only means protection of creative works, but also the prevention of unfair competition and the safeguarding of cultural heritage. So, are you ready to take on the global copyright wars?


By : Intellectual Property, Entertainment, Media and Sports

Our legal practice group specializes in intellectual property, entertainment, media and sports law, offering comprehensive expertise and services for clients seeking to protect their creative works and navigate the ever-changing media landscape.


Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Legal & Industry Updates
Sign up to receive CQ Legal Insights and updates.

Join Us

+233 (0) 555 526 811